Peer Review Policies

Scope Note

NIH policies provide instructional guidance to ensure peer review regulations are appropriately implemented and the core values of NIH’s review process are followed. See below for information and resources on key review policies.

Peer Review Integrity and Confidentiality

Integrity and Confidentiality in NIH Peer Review

Policy Notices

  • Maintaining Security and Confidentiality in NIH Peer Review: Rules, Responsibilities and Possible Consequences (NOT-OD-22-044)
  • The Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence Technologies is Prohibited for the NIH Peer Review Process (NOT-OD-23-149)

FAQs

Conflict of Interest

Managing Conflict of Interest in NIH Peer Review of Grants and Contracts

Policy Notices

  • Advance Notice: Revised Policy for Managing Conflict of Interest in the Initial Peer Review of NIH Grant and Cooperative Agreement Applications (NOT-OD-13-010)

FAQs

Review Criteria

Peer Review Criteria and Considerations 

Revisions to the NIH Fellowship Application and Review Process

Policy Notices

  • Implementation of Revisions to the NIH and AHRQ Fellowship Application and Review Process (NOT-OD-24-107)
  • Simplified Review Framework for NIH Research Project Grant Applications (NOT-OD-24-010)

FAQs

Scoring

Scoring in First Level Peer Review

Policy Notice

  • Enhancing Peer Review: The NIH Announces New Scoring Procedures for Evaluation of Research Applications (NOT-OD-09-024)

FAQs

Appeals

Appeals in First Level Peer Review

Policy Notice

FAQs


This page last updated on: November 13, 2026
For technical issues E-mail OER Webmaster