Summary Feedback and Interim Next Steps for NIH-Supported Research Involving Laboratory Cephalopods
In 2023, NIH sought public feedback on Proposed Guidance to Assured Institutions on Cephalopod Care and Use (NOT-OD-23-176). Since then, we have thoughtfully considered each response and shared the summary of that input on our Cephalopods in Research page.
Cephalopods are a class of invertebrate aquatic animals that includes octopuses, nautiluses, squid, and cuttlefish. Research involving these animals has provided valuable insight into the science of learning, motion and movement, behavior, and nervous system development. Recent initiatives to formalize standards for cephalopod care and use are helping to ensure continued humane treatment and address principles of the 3Rs (Replacement, Reduction, and Refinement).
Reiterating points in this archived NIH Extramural Nexus article, we acknowledge that applying the Public Health Service Policy on Humane Care and Use of Laboratory Animals (PHS Policy) to cephalopods is currently challenging in part due to the lack of scientific understanding and species-specific standards of care. Relatedly, the Guide for Care and Use of Laboratory Animals acknowledges that laboratory animal science is a rapidly evolving field, and there are several areas in which current available scientific information is insufficient and additional objective information and assessment are needed to provide a scientific basis for recommendations.
What We Heard From Commenters
We received 75 comments, providing substantive information and detailed recommendations for our consideration. Comments reflected multiple positions, both supporting and expressing concerns:
Support
- Proposed guidance provides protections while maintaining flexibility for institutions and Institutional Animal Care and Use Committees (IACUCs).
Concerns
- Proposed measures were insufficient to improve welfare.
- Legal and procedural barriers exist, including limitations of applying the U.S. Government Principles for the Utilization and Care of Vertebrate Animals Used in Testing, Research, and Training to invertebrates.
- The definition of “animal” in the PHS Policy (III.A) currently does not include cephalopod invertebrates.
- The current edition of the Guide does not address cephalopods in detail but does establish general principles and ethical considerations that are applicable to these species (Guide p. 2). The Guide is developed independently by the National Academies and required to be used for recipient institutions performing NIH-funded animal research (PHS Policy IV.A.1).
NIH Office of Laboratory Animal Welfare (OLAW) Interpretations Based on These Comments:
- Applying international guidelines may not address the needs of U.S. institutions, as guidelines adopted in other countries are employed under distinct regulatory and scientific frameworks; cephalopod usage also varies globally.
- Current guidelines reveal significant gaps that necessitate further research to address cephalopod welfare and develop scientifically supported standards of care.
- Commenters shared that funding is needed for basic research in cephalopod biology and welfare to develop data-driven standards necessary for establishing a regulatory compliance framework.
Future Considerations for NIH
Clear standards for the care and use of cephalopods need to be provided in the context of our existing oversight system. Without such standards in the Guide:
- Institutions would have difficulties determining how to achieve and maintain compliance.
- Evaluation of compliance would be difficult to assess, determine, and monitor, as well as be consistently applied, for both recipients and NIH.
- Current gaps in knowledge impede the development of such standards for laboratory cephalopods, including understanding, evaluating, and managing pain and distress; methods of euthanasia; and species-specific requirements.
An August 2026 snapshot of NIH funding identified 11 currently active grants using live laboratory cephalopods. Though it is a limited number of projects, it remains critical to address the welfare of the animals involved using evidence-based information, while also appreciating the complexity and range of species-specific welfare needs.
As a science-based organization, NIH will continue to review scientific data relating to animal welfare and biology as it emerges, including for laboratory cephalopods. Considering this point and the feedback received, we are awaiting further development of evidence-based standards and release of the next edition of the Guide before releasing any final guidance.
In the interim, OLAW encourages institutions to:
- Continue to take steps to ensure the humane care and use of invertebrates.
- Refer to professional publications for husbandry, minimization of pain and distress, and management best practices.
IACUCs have the discretion to oversee studies involving cephalopods as they would vertebrate animals and are encouraged to do so.